Your Pool, Your Decision: Pool Resurfacing vs. Pool Replastering

Maintaining your pool is essential for a safe, beautiful, and enjoyable swimming experience. It not only prolongs the life of your pool but also improves its aesthetic appeal and functionality.

However, one common dilemma that many pool owners face is deciding between pool resurfacing and replastering. The difference between these two options can be confusing, but understanding their differences is key to making the right choice for your pool.

In this article, we’ll explain pool resurfacing and replastering and guide you through their processes, costs, durability, aesthetics, and maintenance requirements. By the end, you’ll know which is the best solution for keeping your pool in great state.

Understanding Pool Resurfacing

Pool resurfacing is a critical aspect of pool maintenance that ensures your pool remains safe, functional, and aesthetically pleasing. Let’s explore what it is, how long it lasts, and when to do it.

What It Entails

Pool resurfacing involves various steps to renew your pool’s surface. First, the pool is drained, and any loose or damaged material is removed, often through sandblasting or hydroblasting. This creates a rough surface for better adhesion.

Next, a bonding agent is applied to help the new surface stick properly. Then the chosen finish, such as plaster, tile, pebble, or fiberglass, is carefully applied. Each material has its unique characteristics and benefits; pebble surfaces are durable and textured, while plaster provides a smooth, classic look.

How Long Does It Last?

The lifespan of a resurfaced pool largely depends on the materials used and the quality of work. On average, a well-resurfaced pool lasts 10 to 20 years. For instance, a plaster finish lasts about 10 to 15 years, while a pebble finish can extend beyond 20 years with proper care.

Several factors affect this duration, including the quality of water upkeep, pool usage, and environmental conditions. Regular maintenance and proper chemical balance are essential to prevent premature wear and extend the life of your pool’s new surface.

When to Resurface Your Pool

Here are some signs it’s time for resurfacing:

• Cracks and Leaks: Visible cracks or leaks in your pool surface indicate structural issues that need immediate attention.
• Rough Surfaces: If the surface feels rough, it can be uncomfortable and even dangerous for swimmers.
• Discoloration and Stains: Persistent blemish or taint that don’t come off with cleaning might suggest deep-seated issues in the surface material.
• Chipping or Peeling: Materials that chip or peel away expose the underlying layers and can lead to more severe problems if left untreated.

What Is Pool Replastering?

Pool replastering renews the plaster surface of a swimming pool to maintain its structural integrity and visual appeal. It not only enhances the pool’s appearance but also ensures the comfort and safety of swimmers.

What It Involves

Replastering a pool starts with draining the pool and removing the old, damaged plaster. The surface is then thoroughly cleaned to remove any debris or contaminants.

Next, a bonding agent is applied to create a strong adhesive layer for the new plaster. The new plaster mixture, typically made of white cement and marble dust, is spread evenly across the pool’s surface, often in multiple coats, to achieve an even and uniform finish. It’s essential to keep the plaster wet during the curing process to ensure proper hardening and durability.

Expected Duration

The lifespan of a replastered pool can vary based on several factors but generally ranges from 10 to 15 years. Using high-quality materials and professional application can make the finish last even longer.

Factors influencing the longevity of replastering involve water maintenance, pool use, and environmental exposure. Well-maintained pools with balanced chemicals usually last longer. Routine cleaning and timely repairs help maximize the strength of a replastered pool.

Indicators for Replastering

Look for these common signs:

• Surface Peeling: Peeling or flaking plaster exposes the underlying layers and weakens the pool’s surface.
• Staining: Persistent blemishes and discoloration, especially those not resolved by regular cleaning, suggest deep issues in the plaster.
• Rough Texture: A rough or sandpaper-like surface can be uncomfortable and abrasive for swimmers.
• Chipping and Cracks: Visible chipping or cracks show structural wear that needs to be fixed to prevent further harm.

Differences Between Resurfacing and Replastering

Understanding the differences between pool resurfacing and replastering helps in making an informed decision about your pool’s maintenance. Both renew and preserve the pool’s surface but differ in methods, costs, durability, aesthetics, and maintenance.

Comparing the Processes

Resurfacing involves a complete renewal of the pool’s surface using materials like tile, pebble, fiberglass, or plaster. It includes draining the pool, removing the old surface, applying a bonding agent, and adding the new material.

Replastering, on the other hand, focuses on renewing the plaster layer. It removes the old plaster, cleans the pool surface, applies a bonding agent, and then spreads a new plaster coat. Resurfacing offers a wider variety of finishes, making it a more versatile option.

Cost Comparison

Resurfacing generally costs more due to the variety of materials and complexity. It ranges from $5,000 to $15,000, depending on the materials and pool size. Replastering is cheaper, ranging from $3,500 to $7,000. Labor costs are higher for resurfacing due to the specialized skills required.

Durability and Longevity

Resurfacing materials like pebble or fiberglass can last over 20 years. Replastering typically lasts 10 to 15 years. Longevity depends on material option, quality of application, and maintenance. Proper water balance, routine cleaning, and repairs extend the life of both.

Aesthetic Outcomes

Resurfacing offers many aesthetic options with various textures and colors, allowing for unique designs. Pebble and tile finishes can create a luxurious appearance. Replastering offers a classic, smooth look that can be tinted in different colors. Resurfacing allows for more creative designs.

Upkeep and Care

Maintaining a resurfaced pool depends on the material. Pebble and tile necessitates regular brushing and occasional deep cleaning to prevent algae.

Fiberglass surfaces are relatively low maintenance but need proper water balance to avoid staining. Replastered pools require consistent water chemistry and regular brushing to prevent algae and blemishing. Regular inspections and timely repairs are essential for both.

How to Choose the Best Option for Your Pool

Choosing between pool resurfacing and replastering depends on your pool’s current status, aesthetic preferences, and budget. Here’s how to make an informed decision:

Assessing Your Pool’s Condition

If your pool has extensive damage, such as large cracks or significant peeling, resurfacing may be the better option as it provides a more comprehensive solution. For minor wear and tear, surface stains, or a rough texture, replastering can effectively restore the pool’s finish.

Considering Your Preferences

If you want a specific style or texture, such as the luxurious feel of a pebble finish or the sleek look of tiles, resurfacing offers more variety of materials and customization. For a classic, flawless finish, replastering is a straightforward and effective choice.

Evaluating Your Budget

Resurfacing generally costs more upfront due to materials and labor but lasts longer. Replastering is cheaper initially but may need more frequent upgrades. Consider long-term costs, including maintenance and future repairs, to decide which option fits your budget.

Choosing What’s Right for Your Pool

Deciding between pool resurfacing and replastering ultimately depends on the process, cost, durability, aesthetics, and upkeep. Let’s recap these comparisons to assist you make an informed decision.

Resurfacing offers a variety of materials and finishes, providing more aesthetic and functional options. It is generally more expensive but often results in a longer-lasting surface. Replastering is more limited in material choices but offers a classic and budget-friendly option with a shorter lifespan.

In terms of resilience, resurfacing materials like pebble or fiberglass can last over 20 years, whereas plaster normally lasts around 10 to 15 years. Aesthetics vary, with resurfacing allowing for more customization and unique textures, while replastering offers a refine and traditional look.

Maintenance needs also differ; resurfaced pools require care depending on the material used, and replastered pools need regular brushing and chemical balance to prevent wear.

Taking proactive steps in pool upkeep is crucial for ensuring a safe, beautiful, and long-lasting swimming environment. Whether you choose resurfacing or replastering, regular check-ups and proper care will keep your pool in top status for years to come.

Keep Your Pool Pristine Post-Resurfacing or Replastering

Taking that next step in pool care?

Whether you’ve just resurfaced or replastered your pool, proper maintenance is key to preserving its beauty and functionality.

At Poolie, we offer ongoing support to keep your pool in pristine condition.

Fill out the form below to connect with a Poolie team member. We’ll tailor a maintenance plan to ensure your pool remains a source of joy and relaxation for years to come.

We’re here to help you protect your investment and enjoy a flawless swimming experience.